{ "records": [ { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1567.2627449035645, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 8.725919008255005, "method": "CB-SSD", "proof_rate": 0.7777777777777778, "proved": 28, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 11, "limit_without_incumbent": 1, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2591.383086204529, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 19.236103415489197, "method": "CB-ASD", "proof_rate": 0.6666666666666666, "proved": 24, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 2, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2828.218939065933, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 12.399023056030273, "method": "CB-SSD", "proof_rate": 0.9444444444444444, "proved": 34, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 12, "limit_without_incumbent": 1, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2823.889571905136, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 9.15460991859436, "method": "CB-ASD", "proof_rate": 0.6388888888888888, "proved": 23, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2873.767329931259, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 12.442100048065186, "method": "CB-SSD", "proof_rate": 0.8611111111111112, "proved": 31, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 10, "limit_without_incumbent": 1, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 602.8169131278992, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 7.847233057022095, "method": "CB-ASD", "proof_rate": 0.6944444444444444, "proved": 25, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1191.6795048713684, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 20.226725101470947, "method": "CB-SSD", "proof_rate": 0.875, "proved": 21, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 10, "limit_without_incumbent": 1, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 731.6071450710297, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 9.41271185874939, "method": "CB-ASD", "proof_rate": 0.5416666666666666, "proved": 13, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 2, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1204.5996179580688, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 22.284260988235474, "method": "CB-SSD", "proof_rate": 0.9166666666666666, "proved": 22, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 10, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2689.971384048462, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 22.419856429100037, "method": "CB-ASD", "proof_rate": 0.5833333333333334, "proved": 14, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1865.0605528354645, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 22.290398120880127, "method": "CB-SSD", "proof_rate": 0.7916666666666666, "proved": 19, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 13, "limit_without_incumbent": 1, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 379.24076294898987, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 155.64936006069183, "method": "CB-ASD", "proof_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "proved": 10, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 12, "limit_without_incumbent": 3, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 566.610148191452, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 31.82354092597961, "method": "SSD", "proof_rate": 0.5833333333333334, "proved": 21, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 13, "limit_without_incumbent": 4, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2085.3349599838257, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 103.40103197097778, "method": "ASD", "proof_rate": 0.5277777777777778, "proved": 19, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 14, "limit_without_incumbent": 9, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3158.1377041339874, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 549.9417378902435, "method": "KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.3611111111111111, "proved": 13, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 25, "limit_without_incumbent": 11, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 9, "limit_without_incumbent": 6, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1575.2541909217834, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 250.74675703048703, "method": "CB-KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.5833333333333334, "proved": 21, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 19, "limit_without_incumbent": 15, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 150.73216915130615, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 85.91964304447174, "method": "CB-KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "proved": 2, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 36, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "MibS", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 3, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1554.6711430549622, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 29.75484907627106, "method": "SSD", "proof_rate": 0.7777777777777778, "proved": 28, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 13, "limit_without_incumbent": 4, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2257.243005990982, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 27.59443306922913, "method": "ASD", "proof_rate": 0.5277777777777778, "proved": 19, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 9, "limit_without_incumbent": 6, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 600.9365520477295, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 179.07694101333618, "method": "KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.5833333333333334, "proved": 21, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 21, "limit_without_incumbent": 12, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 27.014430046081543, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 6.13869309425354, "method": "KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "proved": 3, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2153.561884880066, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 85.47702157497406, "method": "CB-KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.7777777777777778, "proved": 28, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 21, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 24.40980815887451, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 5.275150537490845, "method": "CB-KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "proved": 10, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 36, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "MibS", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 6, "limit_without_incumbent": 3, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3016.24125790596, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 26.5541570186615, "method": "SSD", "proof_rate": 0.75, "proved": 27, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 10, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2885.4541339874268, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 32.24535298347473, "method": "ASD", "proof_rate": 0.5833333333333334, "proved": 21, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 11, "limit_without_incumbent": 6, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 981.6196930408478, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 78.47008919715881, "method": "KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.5277777777777778, "proved": 19, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 18, "limit_without_incumbent": 9, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1896.094164133072, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 5.488005876541138, "method": "KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.25, "proved": 9, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3285.690187931061, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 68.51472401618958, "method": "CB-KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.7777777777777778, "proved": 28, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 17, "limit_without_incumbent": 8, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3536.6198959350586, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 3.8964011669158936, "method": "CB-KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.3055555555555556, "proved": 11, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 36, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "MibS", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 2, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3046.242588996887, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 50.132551193237305, "method": "SSD", "proof_rate": 0.7083333333333334, "proved": 17, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 12, "limit_without_incumbent": 2, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 647.5293719768524, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 50.12313711643219, "method": "ASD", "proof_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "proved": 10, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 4, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1171.8894050121307, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 141.43830943107605, "method": "KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.5, "proved": 12, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 19, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 7, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3192.3935029506683, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 131.77324104309082, "method": "CB-KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.7083333333333334, "proved": 17, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 14, "limit_without_incumbent": 6, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2055.441327095032, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 67.95929706096649, "method": "CB-KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "proved": 4, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 24, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "MibS", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 4, "limit_without_incumbent": 2, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3119.2808589935303, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 44.002068519592285, "method": "SSD", "proof_rate": 0.75, "proved": 18, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 11, "limit_without_incumbent": 2, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2746.3557121753693, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 297.4363920688629, "method": "ASD", "proof_rate": 0.4583333333333333, "proved": 11, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2413.8408319950104, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 240.87330293655396, "method": "KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.5833333333333334, "proved": 14, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 13, "limit_without_incumbent": 7, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 272.7724440097809, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 92.62431001663208, "method": "KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "proved": 4, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 6, "limit_without_incumbent": 2, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3226.691584825516, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 119.80696845054626, "method": "CB-KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.6666666666666666, "proved": 16, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 12, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 143.09861707687378, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 27.242353916168213, "method": "CB-KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.2916666666666667, "proved": 7, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 24, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "MibS", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 2, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1616.5776691436768, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 77.20547747612, "method": "SSD", "proof_rate": 0.5833333333333334, "proved": 14, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 14, "limit_without_incumbent": 2, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3373.2602400779724, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 335.35005402565, "method": "ASD", "proof_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "proved": 8, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 7, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3249.9212939739227, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 588.9230794906616, "method": "KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.5, "proved": 12, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 20, "limit_without_incumbent": 4, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 3, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3159.022749900818, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 364.5760455131531, "method": "CB-KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.6666666666666666, "proved": 16, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 18, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 16.198303937911987, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 16.198303937911987, "method": "CB-KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.041666666666666664, "proved": 1, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 24, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "MibS", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 18.83521364699118, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.920160385518102, "method": "IOM-Top1 (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 36, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1927.4552049320191, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 3.3688525930047035, "method": "IOM-Top1 (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.8611111111111112, "proved": 31, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 7.968842167989351, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.7119301675411407, "method": "IOM-Top1 (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 36, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2759.0568240160355, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 2.456861696962733, "method": "IOM-Top1 (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.7777777777777778, "proved": 28, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 15, "limit_without_incumbent": 20, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 69.49597147409804, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 69.49597147409804, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.027777777777777776, "proved": 1, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 6, "limit_without_incumbent": 30, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 7.469932348001748, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.7440894320025109, "method": "IOM-Top1 (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 36, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 6, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2020.5312577409784, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 2.4647049804916605, "method": "IOM-Top1 (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.8333333333333334, "proved": 30, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 6, "limit_without_incumbent": 21, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2833.9767119849566, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 7.762194768991321, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.25, "proved": 9, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 23, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 18.22468452900648, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.5698406439623795, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "proved": 10, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 13.69135613401886, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 1.1545881440397352, "method": "IOM-Top1 (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 24, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 506.50732443400193, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 2.4902894495171495, "method": "IOM-Top1 (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.6666666666666666, "proved": 16, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 21, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 21, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 28.300673112040386, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 1.1802414904232137, "method": "IOM-Top1 (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 24, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 7, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2959.008591888007, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 6.1401244070148095, "method": "IOM-Top1 (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.7083333333333334, "proved": 17, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 7, "limit_without_incumbent": 14, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1952.815943649999, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 152.08525808807462, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.125, "proved": 3, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 19, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 27.51872242998797, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 1.3713198404875584, "method": "IOM-Top1 (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 24, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 11, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 914.649340386968, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 3.188336252002045, "method": "IOM-Top1 (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.5416666666666666, "proved": 13, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 12.415881449938752, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.3938761489698663, "method": "IOM-All (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 36, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2882.753300269949, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 2.840818544034846, "method": "IOM-All (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.8611111111111112, "proved": 31, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 30, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 4.806964048068039, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.4610086414613761, "method": "IOM-All (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 36, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2736.544818615075, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 1.8561661000130698, "method": "IOM-All (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.7777777777777778, "proved": 28, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 15, "limit_without_incumbent": 20, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 48.66019113804214, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 48.66019113804214, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.027777777777777776, "proved": 1, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 6, "limit_without_incumbent": 30, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 35, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 7.276023090002127, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.3322418380412273, "method": "IOM-All (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 36, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 7, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1451.6762716590893, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.9498630879679696, "method": "IOM-All (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.8055555555555556, "proved": 29, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 7, "limit_without_incumbent": 21, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 203.10171440104023, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 6.165176335023716, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "proved": 8, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 23, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 111.5666395240696, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.417605383991031, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "proved": 10, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 36, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 40, "tasks": 36 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 7.224732575006783, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.6836566254496574, "method": "IOM-All (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 24, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 974.5560849650064, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 1.9677203119499609, "method": "IOM-All (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.6666666666666666, "proved": 16, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 21, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 3, "limit_without_incumbent": 21, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 45, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 7.357354869949631, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.724748045031447, "method": "IOM-All (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 24, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 8, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3188.931901011034, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 1.6466198560665362, "method": "IOM-All (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.6666666666666666, "proved": 16, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 7, "limit_without_incumbent": 14, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 162.23089786001947, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 50.53179885901045, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.125, "proved": 3, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 5, "limit_without_incumbent": 19, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 50, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 15.828084426000714, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.91391158150509, "method": "IOM-All (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 24, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 11, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 712.5929504970554, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 3.0377233650069684, "method": "IOM-All (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.5416666666666666, "proved": 13, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 24, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": 55, "tasks": 24 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 25, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2873.767329931259, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 14.396095037460327, "method": "CB-SSD", "proof_rate": 0.8611111111111112, "proved": 155, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 66, "limit_without_incumbent": 5, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2823.889571905136, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 15.934408187866213, "method": "CB-ASD", "proof_rate": 0.6055555555555555, "proved": 109, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 40, "limit_without_incumbent": 15, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3119.2808589935303, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 35.50568509101868, "method": "SSD", "proof_rate": 0.6944444444444444, "proved": 125, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 73, "limit_without_incumbent": 19, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3373.2602400779724, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 78.45438611507416, "method": "ASD", "proof_rate": 0.4888888888888889, "proved": 88, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 52, "limit_without_incumbent": 37, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3249.9212939739227, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 171.5171229839325, "method": "KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.5055555555555555, "proved": 91, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 116, "limit_without_incumbent": 48, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 1896.094164133072, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 9.29299247264862, "method": "KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.08888888888888889, "proved": 16, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 33, "limit_without_incumbent": 21, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3285.690187931061, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 142.28879749774933, "method": "CB-KKT-BigM", "proof_rate": 0.7, "proved": 126, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 101, "limit_without_incumbent": 44, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3536.6198959350586, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 16.198303937911987, "method": "CB-KKT-SOS1", "proof_rate": 0.19444444444444445, "proved": 35, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 180, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "MibS", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 28.300673112040386, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.9495488835091237, "method": "IOM-Top1 (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 180, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 45, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2959.008591888007, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 2.5914065029937774, "method": "IOM-Top1 (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.75, "proved": 135, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 31, "limit_without_incumbent": 136, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 2833.9767119849566, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 69.49597147409804, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.07222222222222222, "proved": 13, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 17, "limit_without_incumbent": 153, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 18.22468452900648, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.5698406439623795, "method": "IOM-Top1 (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "proved": 10, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 180, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-Top1 (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 15.828084426000714, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.528289006993873, "method": "IOM-All (SSD)", "proof_rate": 1.0, "proved": 180, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 47, "limit_without_incumbent": 0, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 3188.931901011034, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 2.0988460250082426, "method": "IOM-All (ASD)", "proof_rate": 0.7388888888888889, "proved": 133, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 32, "limit_without_incumbent": 136, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 203.10171440104023, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 16.98317430203315, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-BigM)", "proof_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "proved": 12, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 17, "limit_without_incumbent": 153, "max_proved_solver_seconds": 111.5666395240696, "median_proved_solver_seconds": 0.417605383991031, "method": "IOM-All (KKT-SOS1)", "proof_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "proved": 10, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 }, { "limit_with_incumbent": 0, "limit_without_incumbent": 180, "max_proved_solver_seconds": null, "median_proved_solver_seconds": null, "method": "IOM-All (MibS)", "proof_rate": 0.0, "proved": 0, "source_size": "all", "tasks": 180 } ], "schema_version": 1 }